Why You’ll Love This Rum Old Fashioned Recipe
You’ll love this Rum Old Fashioned recipe because it brings a revitalizing twist to a classic cocktail.
I’ve always enjoyed the rich history behind the Old Fashioned, but when I discovered how rum can elevate its flavors, I was hooked.
The sweetness from fresh pineapple and the depth of dark brown sugar create a perfect balance, while the bitters add just the right amount of complexity.
It’s not just a drink; it’s an experience that transports me to a tropical paradise with every sip.
Trust me, once you try this version, you’ll never look at the Old Fashioned the same way again.
Ingredients of Rum Old Fashioned
When you’re ready to whip up a delicious Rum Old Fashioned, let’s take a look at what you’ll need. The ingredients are straightforward, but they pack a punch of flavor that’s just delightful.
This cocktail isn’t just for sipping on a sunny beach; it’s perfect for cozy nights at home or impressing your friends at a gathering. So gather your ingredients, and let’s get to mixing!
Ingredients:
- 1 piece fresh pineapple (1-inch thick)
- 1 maraschino cherry
- 1 teaspoon dark brown sugar
- 1 dash Angostura bitters
- Ice cubes
- 1 1/2 ounces light rum
- 1/4 cup club soda
Now, let’s chat about these ingredients. Fresh pineapple is a game-changer here; it brings that juicy sweetness that you just can’t get from a syrup.
And let’s face it, who doesn’t love a good chunk of pineapple? The maraschino cherry adds a touch of nostalgia, reminding you of classic cocktails from the past, right?
The dark brown sugar doesn’t just sweeten; it also adds a hint of molasses flavor that really deepens the drink. Bitters might sound fancy, but they’re like the secret handshake of cocktail-making—just a dash can elevate your drink from ordinary to extraordinary.
And of course, we can’t forget the light rum and club soda, which balance everything out perfectly. So, grab your cocktail shaker and let’s get ready for a tasty adventure!
How to Make Rum Old Fashioned

Making a Rum Old Fashioned is simpler than you might think, and trust me, once you’ve had one, you’ll want to whip them up all the time.
Start with one piece of fresh pineapple about an inch thick—yes, the fresh stuff is essential for that juicy sweetness. Place that pineapple in an old-fashioned glass along with one maraschino cherry, a teaspoon of dark brown sugar, and a dash of Angostura bitters.
Now, here’s where you can really get in there: muddle those ingredients together. Use a pestle or the back of a wooden spoon to mash it all into a chunky pulp. You want to release the juices from the pineapple and mix them with the sugar and bitters. It’s like a mini workout for your arms, and honestly, who doesn’t love a little exertion before cocktail hour?
Once you’ve got that delightful mixture ready, it’s time for the ice. Fill the glass with ice cubes, making sure to pack them in there because, let’s face it, no one wants a lukewarm drink.
Now, pour in 1 1/2 ounces of light rum. If you’re feeling fancy, pretend you’re in a tropical paradise while doing this—maybe even hum a little tune.
Then top it off with 1/4 cup of club soda. Give it a good stir until everything is well combined. The sound of clinking ice and the sight of those vibrant colors swirling together is pure joy.
Seriously, if you don’t take a moment to appreciate your handiwork, are you even making cocktails?
And there you have it: a revitalizing Rum Old Fashioned. Sip it slowly, savor it, and maybe even share a sip with a friend—if you’re feeling generous.
Just remember, this cocktail is perfect for cozy nights at home or when you want to impress your pals at a gathering.
And if they ask for the recipe, just smile mysteriously and say it’s a secret. After all, the best cocktails are the ones that feel a little magical, right?
Rum Old Fashioned Substitutions & Variations
Once you’ve mastered the classic Rum Old Fashioned, there’s a whole world of substitutions and variations to explore.
You might try using spiced rum for a warmer flavor or even coconut rum for a tropical twist. Instead of pineapple, muddle in fresh berries or citrus for a revitalizing change.
If you want to skip the club soda, replacing it with ginger beer can add a nice kick. For sweetness, experiment with different sugars like maple syrup or agave.
Don’t hesitate to adjust bitters, too—orange or cherry bitters can create unique flavor profiles.
Enjoy personalizing your drink!
Additional Tips & Notes
To elevate your Rum Old Fashioned experience, I suggest paying attention to the quality of your ingredients.
Using fresh pineapple and a good brand of light rum can make a world of difference. Don’t skip the bitters; they add depth and balance.
If you like a sweeter drink, experiment with different sugars, like demerara or simple syrup.
Remember, muddling gently is key; you want to release the flavors without turning everything to mush.
Finally, chill your glass beforehand for that extra revitalizing touch.
Enjoy experimenting, and don’t hesitate to adjust the recipe to fit your personal taste!